"She Done Him Wrong," directed by Lowell Sherman and starring the incomparable Mae West and a young Cary Grant, is a delightful piece of Hollywood's golden age. Released in 1933, this pre-Code film captures the essence of its era with its blend of humor, romance, and drama, making it an enduring classic that continues to charm audiences.
Mae West, who also wrote the play on which the film is based, delivers a performance that is both captivating and iconic. Her portrayal of Lady Lou, a sassy and seductive nightclub singer, is nothing short of mesmerizing. West's sharp wit and undeniable charisma shine brightly, delivering some of the most memorable lines in cinema history. Her presence alone is enough to elevate the film, and her chemistry with Cary Grant adds an extra layer of charm.
Cary Grant, in one of his earlier roles, plays Captain Cummings, a seemingly upright Salvation Army officer with a secret. Grant's natural charm and screen presence are evident, and he provides the perfect foil to West's larger-than-life character. Their interactions are delightful, and Grant's subtle performance hints at the screen legend he would soon become.
The film's lively atmosphere is one of its greatest strengths. The nightclub setting is vibrant and filled with colorful characters, from shady criminals to exuberant performers. The costumes and set design effectively transport the audience to the bustling nightlife of 1890s New York, adding to the film's overall appeal.
However, while "She Done Him Wrong" excels in many areas, it is not without its flaws. The plot, though engaging, could benefit from more depth. The story revolves around Lady Lou's entanglements with various men, including her former lover and current suitors, culminating in a climactic showdown. While entertaining, the narrative lacks the complexity that could have made it truly compelling. A more intricate storyline with additional twists and turns would have enhanced the film's impact.
Moreover, the pacing of the film could be improved. At times, the plot moves too slowly, with certain scenes feeling drawn out. Tightening the pacing would maintain the audience's engagement and keep the momentum going throughout the film.
Another area that could use improvement is the development of supporting characters. While West and Grant deliver stellar performances, some of the secondary characters lack depth and are reduced to mere caricatures. Providing these characters with more backstory and personality would add richness to the film and make their interactions with the leads more meaningful.
The musical numbers, though entertaining, can also feel somewhat repetitive. While they showcase Mae West's talent and add to the nightclub ambiance, a greater variety in the songs and performances would prevent them from feeling redundant. Incorporating different styles of music and choreography could enhance the film's entertainment value.
Despite these minor flaws, "She Done Him Wrong" remains a timeless favorite and a must-watch for fans of vintage cinema. Its strengths far outweigh its weaknesses, and the film's historical significance cannot be overstated. It was one of the few films at the time to feature a strong, independent female lead, and Mae West's influence on the industry is undeniable.
In conclusion, "She Done Him Wrong" is a delightful and entertaining film that showcases the best of Hollywood's golden age. While it could benefit from a more complex plot, improved pacing, better-developed supporting characters, and more varied musical numbers, these are minor quibbles in an otherwise charming film. Mae West's iconic performance and the film's lively atmosphere ensure its place in cinema history, making it a must-see for any film enthusiast.
1 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink