Lumiere's First Picture Shows (TV Movie 2013) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
1 Review
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
An excellent primer on the Lumière brothers
jimjo121613 January 2014
I am an amateur student of film history and had heard the Lumière brothers (Louis and Auguste) mentioned as film pioneers. They even get a shout-out in director Martin Scorsese's recent ode to film history HUGO (2011). Yet I had never had the opportunity to see any of their films or learn much about them. Thanks to TCM and its programming tie-in to the STORY OF FILM: AN ODYSSEY (2010) documentary series, I was finally able to sample dozens of the Lumières' films in this half-hour compilation.

LUMIERE'S FIRST PICTURE SHOWS compiles over twenty very short films from the dawn of cinema, only covering about three years' time (1895-1897). Included are a variety of films, mostly documenting real-life in short snippets. Parades, firefighters, trains, pedestrians, etc. There are also some more staged films, including a water hose prank.

In the earliest days of filmmaking, the novelty was the motion captured in the image. So early films were created of mundane subjects like a crowd of people leaving work, parents feeding their child, or a train pulling into a station. Anything that could capture "life", when projected onto a wall, would wow the audience. The film used in the Lumières' patented cinematograph camera only took about a minute of footage, so the Lumière films are quick snippets of life, without room for elaborate storytelling.

The compilation presented here includes several famous Lumière Bros. shorts that are must-see films for film history buffs ("La sortie des usines Lumière", "L'arrivée d'un train à La Ciotat", etc.) as well as more rare or obscure films from the Lumière catalogue. The shorts are presented more or less chronologically and are accompanied by informative intertitle cards that provide historical context. Through the text, the program basically tells the story of the Lumières' early years of filmmaking, with the films serving as relevant examples of their work. The start of the program includes footage (of unidentified origin) that demonstrates the use of the cinematograph, an early motion picture camera that could also copy film and project it.

The works of the Lumière brothers (and their associates) are fascinating looks back in time. Each minute-long film is like a window into history, a glimpse of the world over a hundred years ago. I particularly like the "actuality" films that show, for instance, the streets of New York City circa 1896. Or the footage of old trains or street cars or policemen marching in formation. The film of President McKinley's 1897 inauguration at the Capitol is neat to see.

Other favorites of mine are "La bataille de neige", a snowball fight that captures a sense of joy that is timeless, and "Querelle enfantine", a clip of two young children in high chairs fighting over toys that shows the full spectrum of human emotions. In only about forty-five seconds, the Lumière Bros. are able to capture humanity on a film strip. That's what makes moving pictures so engaging and so fascinating. Life, bottled up.

One frustrating thing about this program is that the titles of the films are not always clearly presented. The text sometimes alludes to certain films or series of films and then shows two or three back-to-back. Sometimes it's not clear what is being shown, for any viewers keeping score.

This is further complicated by the lack of readily available information on such old films. Viewers can't always cross-reference clips they've seen with descriptions online. Some films presented in this lineup didn't even exist on IMDb. Not everyone has a definitive Lumière Bros. reference tome, and I'd wish the experts out there would make it a little easier for the rest of us.

Toward the end there are three films of American soldiers marching in formation in camp-like settings. The films appear after a card that reads "Washington - Review of the National Guard, Review of the Artillery of the District of Columbia". What little information I could scrape up online shows two Lumière films with corresponding titles, though the content does not appear to match the films featured here. Are the clips misidentified in this compilation? If so, which films are these? And what of the third film?

Taken from the Blackhawk Films archive and presented by Turner Classic Movies, this 2013 program also features music by ubiquitous silent film composer Robert Israel. I'm not sure if this is an all-new compilation of archived shorts or a re-packaged presentation of an older program (this "edition" has copyrights for both 1975 and 2013, and the contextual intertitles don't seem "new"). Either way, LUMIERE'S FIRST PICTURE SHOWS is a quick yet informative introduction to the early days of motion pictures. If it turns up on TCM again, it's worth checking out for anyone even casually interested in the history of filmmaking.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed