- When the Legends discover a new Encore, Sara, Rory and Ava end up crashing a high school reunion to attempt to stop a serial killer from finishing unfinished business. The Legends devise a plan to send Nate, Ray, Nora, Behrad and their hostage Zari, back in time to try and intervene in order to try to save everyone including them. Meanwhile, Constantine is annoyed that Charlie has been squatting in his old home, but it might be the blessing in disguise they were not looking for.
- At Iron Heights Penitentiary in 2004, Freddy Meyers stands convicted of seven counts of murder in June 1989. Freddy says that he loves his mother, and his mother Kathy watches from the gallery. The executioner throws the switch, and Freddy is electrocuted. Kathy breaks into tears and pounds on the glass, saying that they took her Freddy.
In 2004, a coroner in a Central City County vehicle is driving down the highway and hears something move in the back. His brakes fail and the music on the radio goes up in volume. The coroner finally piles into water barrels and then staggers out. He sees a tag with Freddy's name on it, and someone stabs him in the back and then walks away.
On Waverider, Constantine tries to sneak away but Sara catches him. Constantine says that he's leaving before the Legends can pull him into another save-the-world scenario. Sara tells him that they've been waiting for Constantine to move out, Ray catches up to them and suggests they go back in time and reform all of the villains when they're children. Sara and Constantine figure it won't work, and Nora teleports aboard Waverider and calls for Ray.
Ray checks in on Nora and finds her in a horse-riding outfit. She complains that all of the kids she grants wishes for want ponies, and Ray tells her that it's all about what she wants. Nora says that she wants to be done being a fairy godmother, and points out that kids don't know what they need. Ray pours wine and has Gideon play Nora's favorite song, only to discover that Nora has dozed off
Nate and Behrad take Tala to the study, but she still doesn't remember her post life. Behrad prepares to wipe Tala's memories, but Nate stops her and says that they have to restore Tala's memories. Her brother insists that Tala has never had any memories, and tells Tala to stay there while they finish their job. The two men leave, locking Tala in the study.
On the bridge, Gideon reports that a serial killer has escaped Hell and is on the loose in 2004. When Ava sees the body tag from the body the coroner was transporting, she realizes that the killer was Freddy, the Prom Night Slasher. He was #5 on Ava's podcast on serial killers, and she knows all about Freddy's history. The timeline changed when Freddy's face disappear, and Ava says that Tiffany Harper was the final girl. Nate has watched Ava's podcast, and Ray checks the archives and discovers that the 1989 class is having a 15-year reunion that Friday. They figure that Freddy will finish his killings at the reunion.
When the Legends arrive at the high school reunion, Ava fan-girls over the site of Freddy's last rampage. Mick admits that he went to school there, and only remembers Freddy as a loser. Ali comes up and greets Mick, who badly claims that he isn't Mick. As Mick walks off, Ava sees Tiffany and goes over to greet her. Sara says that Tiffany wouldn't remember them because they were losers in high school, and Tiffany gives them name badges.
In the gym, everyone dances while Sara and Ava search the place. Nate and Ray search the parking lot and find a dead police officer in his car. The men report to Sara and Ava that Freddy is there. The former class president announces Tiffany to come up, but there's no sign of Tiffany. The lights go out, then one light comes up revealing a covered chair. The president figures Tiffany is making a dramatic entrance and removes the covered chair, only to reveal Tiffany's skewered corpse.
Sara yells at everyone to stay calm. Nate and Ray spot a masked Freddy going inside, but he telekinetically closes the doors, locking them out. Nate calls the others and warns that they're stuck in a school with the Prom Night Slasher.
Constantine goes to an old house in Northumberland County, UK, in 2020. Gary arrives late, having teleported there, and Constantine says that he lived there once and no one has stepped inside since h left. They go in and find the place torn up. Constantine finds a man sleeping on the stairs, kicks him awake, and wonders what's going on. Three men walk in, and Constantine tells them all to get out. One of them is a shapeshifted Charlie, and says that Constantine told her about the house once. When she refuses to leave, Constantine walks off.
Sara, Ava, and Mick try to find a way out. They find the outside door, and Nate and Ray appear on the other side and say that the doors are telekinetically sealed. Mick is eager to rescue Ali but doesn't let on that he's concerned about her, and Sara suggests that Ray go back in time and fix Freddy.
Ray and Nate take Waverider back to the high school in 1989, go to the school, and find the bullies picking on Freddy. A young Ali asks Freddy to take her to prom, and a surprised Freddy agrees. Nate and Ray look on, and Nate figures that Ali is working with the boys and they're setting Freddy up. The two Legends approach Freddy, say that they're teachers, and turn him to skip the prom to improve his grades. Freddy isn't interested and walks off despite the fact that they insist they're his pals.
In 2004, Ava and Sara explore the hallways and Ava narrates her podcast. One of the guests approaches them, and Freddy telekinetically pulls her into a locker. He then pulls Sara and Ava down the hall and crushes the locker, killing the woman inside.
Nate and Ray return to Waverider and Behrad looks up Freddy's address. Nora hears voices in her head and tells the others, and explains that her fairy godmother sense has locked onto the kid with the greatest need for a wish. She teleports into Freddy's room and finds him trying on a suit. Nora says that she's his fairy godmother and asks him not to kill her. Freddy figures that Nora has to do anything he wishes for, and says that he already knows what he wants.
Kathy knocks on the door and Nora hides. Kathy says that she has popcorn for movie night, and Nora calls Ray. Ray says that if Nora gives Freddy the prom he dreams of, maybe he won't hurt anyone. Freddy tells Kathy that he's going to prom, and Kathy offers to give him a ride. He quickly closes the door and tells Nora that his wish is that the kids never make fun of him again. Freddy wishes for a cool suit, and Nora obliges. He then asks for a pony.
That night, Freddy arrives at prom in a limo provided by Nora. As Freddy and Tiffany greet each other, Nora steps out of the shadows. Freddy leads Tiffany in, and Nate and Ray arrive. Nora asks Ray to go to prom with him, and he links arms with first her and then Nate and they go in.
Tala tries to get out of Waverider, and she sees the totem on Behrad's wrist. She tells him that their parents treat him like some kind of hero, and Behrad says that Tala only cares about herself. Tala insists that she's business, not a sucking void, and Behrad leaves and locks her in.
In 2004, the president tells everyone in the gym that they'll get help. Mick stands guard with his flame gun, and stops Ali who says that she's going to find a way out while the others wait to be killed. When Mick agrees with her, Ali figures that he's really Mick. As they head for the vent Mick used to sneak out when he was a student, they talk about their lives. Ali asks how things would have been if they'd gone to prom together, and Freddy kills Ali. Mick calls the Legends in 1989 and says that they'd better be fixing things as he holds Ali's body.
In 1989, Nora assures Ray that prom isn't lame. The DJ plays a dance number, and Freddy and Tiffany dance. She tells Freddy that he's a good dancer and tries to get him to the center of the dance floor. Ray and the others spot the bullies ready to dump trash on Freddy. Tiffany has second thoughts and, impressed with Freddy, leads him away. The bullies come over and shove Freddy to the ground, and their leader Brad throws throw punch on Freddy's suit. When Tiffany objects, Brad tells her that was how the prank was suppose d to go. Freddy realizes that Tiffany set him up and Brad is glad to explain. Everyone laughs, and Tiffany tells Freddy that it isn't true anymore.
Nora runs over and tries to stop Freddy, saying that it's okay. Freddy walks off, and Nora tells Nate and Ray that high school sucks.
Mick goes looking for Freddy, and he tells Ava and Sara that he and Ali had a prom. He went to juvie but blew Ali off when they were going to go to prom. Sara says that if they succeed then Freddy won't become a serial killer and Ali will live.
In 1989, Nora catches up to Freddy and says that he doesn't want the others to die. She says that she sees more in him then giving in to his demons, and tells Freddy that being himself is a magic stronger than any wish, and being herself is how the right people found her. She asks Freddy what his wish would be to show the bullies what he really is.
The lights in the gym go out, and Freddy appears on a spotlight. He breakdances and Nora provides fireworks, and the students cheer and join Freddy. When Brad tries to drop garbage on Freddy, Nora magically stops him. Tiffany dances over to Freddy.
Tala accesses Waverider's computer using her memories from the other timeline when she was a hacker. She opens the bulkhead door and tells Gideon to call her a ride.
At the 1989 prom, Freddy goes over to Nora and says that her job is saving kids. Once she says that it is, Freddy thanks her for everything. Nora realizes her mission is completed.
Tala leaves Waverider and gets into Freddy's limo. Meanwhile, Freddy, Tiffany, and several other girls arrive and get in. Tala isn't thrilled to learn she has a shared rider. Meanwhile, the real Slasher watches them.
Behrad tells Mick, Sara, and Ava t5hat Ray fixed things in 1984. The 2004 Prom Slasher appears and Mick shoots him, but the Slasher reflects the flames back on Mick, killing him. The slasher's mask disappears, revealing that "he" is Kathy. Kathy says that they took "her" Freddy away from him, and she knew she had to kill Tiffany and all the other girls who took "her" Freddy away from him.
Tala opens the panel to the driver's seat, and Kathy slashes at them.
Sara and Ava confront Kathy, who says that she won't let anyone stand between her and Freddy. Ava holds off Kathy's knife slashes, and Kathy telekinetically throws Sara down the hallway, knocking her out.
The 1984 Kathy slashes at Tala and the others, then gets out and hacks through the ceiling.
Ava asks Kathy how she got there, and Kathy says that after Freddy took the fall, Kathy couldn't live without her son. She had a heart attack in Iron Heights and died with him, but then was sent back from Hell. She was given a chance to finish the job she started. Sara recovers consciousness, grabs a fire ax, and hits Kathy in the back. While Kathy recovers, Ava is thrilled that they're final girls.
In 1984, Kathy slashes the girls as they get out of the limo.
Sara and Ava grab band instruments and attack Kathy, who throws them away.
Tala sprays perfume in Kathy's face, blinding her. She then rips off Kathy's mask, and Freddy stares at his mother in shock and asks what she's doing. Kathy insists that she's doing it for them, saying she can't live without him.
Kathy grabs the fire ax and prepares to kill Sara and Ava.
The 1989 Kathy says that they can go away together. Freddy refuses to lock himself away, and Kathy tells him that it's for his own good as she prepares to stab him. Behrad arrives and blasts Kathy unconscious using the air totem.
The 2004 Kathy disappears as her 1984 self is stopped.
Tala stares at Behrad in surprise, and realize why he stole the totem. As the police arrive and question everyone, Nora approaches Freddy. He wonders what he does now, and Nora says that dysfunction was her upbringing but dysfunction didn't define her... or Freddy. Before she goes with Ray, Nora tells Freddy that he'll be okay. Touched, Freddy hugs her.
Once the 1989 team is on Waverider, Behrad talks to Tala. She admits that his heroism is why he's the favorite. Behrad points out that their parents only worry about him because they figure he can't handle things. Behrad notes that Tala has been in business for five years, and she explains how she hacked her way out. Her brother dismisses it as a side effect of time travel, and Tala says that she's considering sticking around.
The Legends all meet each other at the gym. Mick is drinking and the restored Ali comes over to him. Freddy and Tiffany are dancing with their spouses, and Ray invites Nora to dance. Sara and Ava dance, and Ava admits that she's thrilled she was a final girl. Behrad leads everyone over to the photo booth and they have their pictures taken together. Sara notices that Mick is gone... and outside, Mick and Ali kiss.
At his house, Constantine is drinking. Charlie joins him and wonders why he isn't doing something about Astra. Constantine talks about how he grew up in the house with his Newcastle Crew, and one of them was a powerful witch. He came back to consult with her, and she's in the next room. Constantine explains that the witch is Astra's dead m other, and not too happy with him. Charlie says that she'd take the chance to walk through a door and solve her problems.
Constantine unseals the door and goes inside, and Charlie tells him that he's got it. He goes into the room and the doors close behind him.
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content