New Mexico pianist Dan O'Dwyer travels back to Tin Pan Alley to find and recover his grandfather Jeremy Todd's never-published songs; soap-opera actress Gina Edwards wants to stop her evil character Angela from using her to come to life.
Roarke is set to marry the love of his life, but Tattoo overhears a conversation that suggests the man who grants others' fantasies may not be able to realize his own.
Mandy Breem sold her soul to the Devil to save her husband Phillip's life and now needs Roarke's help in saving her own; and Tattoo makes Fred Catlett a millionaire for the weekend, only to put the man's life in danger.
Elderly Minnesota physical therapist John Cook wants a last dance with his wife Carol, who passed away six months before; Iowa waitress Adele Anthony, who wants to be treated like a queen, finds herself in the body of Marie Antoinette.
Wealthy businessman Douglas Picard is out to take Fantasy Island away from Roarke; and florist Rebecca Walters enlists the assistance of a genie to find her perfect husband.
Window dresser Francis Elkins is in love with his mannequin Courtney and asks Roarke to bring her to life. Clarissa Bevis enters the world of her favorite classical novel in order to meet Heathcliff.
Tony Chilton returns to World War II in order to meet David, the father he never knew; and Princess Nyah the mermaid asks Roarke to help her learn about human love.
Nyah the mermaid wants to shed her immortality, and promises revenge on Roarke when he refuses her, and meets deep sea diver Duke McCall. Banker Mitch Robinson is faced with being replaced by Charlene Hunt's computer.
Mephistopheles uses Julie to force Roarke into another confrontation; elderly Joan Michaels and Ruby Rogers relive their Ziegfeld Follies days; and Brooklyn shoe salesman Ned Plummer travels to the Old West to meet outlaw Kid Corey.
Interior designer Sheila McKenna is ready to move on after she learns of her husband Frank's affair with her best friend Margot. Accountant Jack Palmer's wife Roxanne takes part in his fantasy of becoming highwayman Dick Turpin.