After stumbling upon a suspicious murder in Blue Valley, the JSA begin looking at potential suspects; a tense run-in with The Shade makes Courtney and Pat realize that Sylvester's old ways could land them in hot water.
After one of Sylvester's plans results in an unexpected outcome, Pat calls upon an old friend for help. Meanwhile, Beth uncovers a new suspect in their murder investigation, and Courtney reaches out to Cameron.
After Beth makes a major discovery on The Gambler's laptop, the team moves forward with a risky plan that effects the entire town of Blue Valley. Elsewhere, Jennie returns to the fold seeking help from Courtney.
Desperate to avert a major crisis on their hands, Courtney attempts to help a friend navigate their powers. Elsewhere, Pat and The Shade are forced to face their worst fears.
Courtney and the team regroup after a dramatic confrontation leaves battle lines clearly drawn; a terrifying discovery made by Mike and Jakeem forces Pat and Sylvester to go on high alert; Paula and Larry take matters into their own hands.